- JCastaway-shotgun-weight-header.png (741.83 KiB) Viewed 7054 times
Picture yourself stepping into a gun shop. The clerk slides a gleaming new shotgun across the counter—a pristine piece of craftsmanship. You lift it, nestle it into your shoulder, and swing the barrel toward an imaginary pheasant streaking across the sky. No matter its type or weight, a single thought flashes through your mind: I could drop ‘em with this. And maybe you could. A decent wingshot can tag a bird with almost any shotgun, provided it fits reasonably well and the choke matches the task. But as you stand there, cradling that shiny newcomer, a question lingers: Would you hit better if it were lighter? Or heavier? Shotgun weight, it turns out, matters more than most hunters realize—a lesson I’ve learned through years of trial, error, and the occasional happy accident.
The Heavy Hitter: A Tale of Triumph and Trouble
Let me take you back a few years. I’d just bought a 12-gauge pump-action—a trap model with a 30-inch barrel, full choke, and a hefty 8-pound frame. It fit me like a glove, a factory-perfect match for my build. My plan? Smash clay targets at the trap range, then take it into the field for high-flying ducks and Canada geese. It arrived just days before a bird-hunting trip to Idaho, so I tossed it into my gear, untested, hoping for a crack at some early-season ducks.
- JCastaway-shotgun-weight-upland-scene.png (616.66 KiB) Viewed 7045 times
The ducks didn’t show—it was too early in the fall—but I wasn’t about to let that stop me. That first morning, I lugged my new 8-pounder along a creek bed, hunting mountain quail with my friend John. He and his pointer soon pulled ahead, crossing the canyon about 50 yards away, when they flushed a big covey. Three quail zipped down the canyon bottom toward me—perfectly spaced, out in the open, about 35 yards off. I shouldered the gun, tracked, and fired three shots. Three birds hit the ground.
After the retrieves, I pushed up the canyon and flushed two singles—longer shots over sagebrush. Two more swings, two more kills. Five for five on mountain quail—a personal best I’ve never matched since. Ted wrapped up his limit shortly after, and we called it a morning. Had I stumbled onto the ultimate upland gun?
Not so fast. Later that trip, I found myself in steeper, rockier terrain, chasing chukars beneath a towering cliff. These birds didn’t mess around—they flushed fast, hugging the contours, curving away or rocketing up the cliff face. Shots rang out around me, and birds dropped, but not for me. When singles popped up close, I had no excuse to rush—yet I’d miss at 20 yards, where the full choke’s tight pattern should’ve shone. At 30 to 35 yards, I’d miss again, with no time for a third shot. By day’s end, I’d scratched down just two chukars, both runners scooped up by Ted’s pointer. “You’re in a mysterious slump,” he said, half-teasing. But it wasn’t a slump. Switching to a nimbler 6¾-pound upland gun for the rest of the trip, I had no more issues. That 8-pound beast had been my undoing.
Why the morning glory and afternoon flop? Simple: weight. On those mountain quail, I’d had time—open sightlines, predictable flight paths, and a steady swing fueled by the gun’s momentum. But chukars demanded speed—quick mounts and snappy swings in tight, chaotic moments. The 8-pounder felt like swinging a sledgehammer.
Heavy Guns, Different Games
Fast-forward two years. I was in Argentina with Jim Rikhoff, hunting ducks and geese with my Winchester 101 trap gun—8¼ pounds, 28-inch barrels, modified and full chokes. After the wildfowling wrapped, we had a spare morning on the windy pampas, stalking tinamou—a partridge-like bird darting through shin-deep grass. Armed with my heavy 101 and Magnum 4 shells, we walked vast, flat fields. The birds flushed 25 yards out, skimming a foot above the clover, riding the wind at dazzling speeds. By the time I swung and fired, shots averaged 35 yards—and to my shock, we dropped them consistently. That heavy gun, once again, proved oddly adept on upland birds.
Then came Scotland, chasing driven grouse. Recalling the tinamou success, I packed the 101 as my first gun. For the second (one for incoming birds, one for going-away shots), I chose a 12-gauge Jeffery side-by-side—6¾ pounds, 28-inch barrels, cylinder and full chokes—a wartime bargain from England. Paired with a trap-shooting buddy wielding his own 7¾-pound doubles, we joined six shooters spaced 40 yards apart below a hillcrest. From chest-deep “butts” dug into the heather, we faced grouse hurtling past like feathered missiles—40 yards out, a yard above the ground, sometimes 20 feet high or 70 yards up. Crossing shots, incomers, outgoing birds—every wingshooting challenge but a flush.
My friend groaned, “It’s like the barrels are full of concrete.” His full-choked heavies bogged him down. My 8¼-pound 101 wasn’t much better—useless on fast, close birds, barely passable on high incomers or distant outgoing shots. But the 6¾-pound Jeffery? It danced—a light, lively wand that turned chaos into kills. Weight, again, made all the difference.
- JCastaway-shotgun-weight-shotgun-ashley.png (507.13 KiB) Viewed 7032 times
The Weight Dilemma: What’s “Just Right”?
So, is there an ideal shotgun weight? When does heavy shine, and when does light take the crown? And what about 2025’s trend toward featherweight models—can a gun be too light?
Heavy Guns (7½–8½ pounds): Think trap, skeet, or deliberate field shots. My Mossberg 590-RM Mag Fed Standoff, a 2025 tactical titan at 9.5 pounds unloaded (up to 11 with accessories), exemplifies the upper end—built for stability, not speed. In trap or skeet, a 7¾-pound gun dampens recoil and sustains a smooth follow-through; once it’s moving, it’s hard to stop. That’s why my 8-pound pump crushed those mountain quail—I could mount it, track, and swing with purpose. Same with the tinamou: open ground, visible targets, time to settle in. But on twitchy chukars or grouse zipping through heather? Forget it. Heavy shines when you see the shot coming and can prep the swing.
Light Guns (5½–6¾ pounds): Enter 2025’s lightest production models, like the Benelli Montefeltro Ultra Light (5.2 pounds in 20-gauge). These are upland royalty—fast to shoulder, quick to point, perfect for surprise flushes in thick cover. My Jeffery in Scotland proved it; so did a 5¼-pound 20-gauge over-under I later tested on grouse and woodcock. That little gun flew to my shoulder, snagged targets mid-flush, and made me wonder why I’d ever hauled anything heavier through brush. Ted Trueblood saw it too—swapping his 7-pound-10-ounce pump for a 7¼-pound double, he marveled, “Half a pound makes a shocking difference.” He was on birds five yards sooner.
Too Light? Here’s the rub. Ray Holland, a grouse-hunting legend, once warned me about his 5¾-pound 20-gauge Woodward: “Too fast—I throw it away.” He meant overswinging—whipping past the target. His pet 12-gauge, a burly 7¾-pounder, suited him best. I felt it myself with that 5¼-pounder on a preserve pheasant—a long crossing shot turned into a wild miss because I couldn’t sustain the swing. Light guns excel up close but falter when reach and momentum matter.
- JCastaway-shotgun-weight-shotgun-geese.png (451.01 KiB) Viewed 7027 times
Finding Your Fit
Imagine trap rules flipped: You yell “Pull!” and hoist your gun from the ground. A 7¾-pounder would feel like a boat anchor; drop to 7¼ or 6¾, and you’d gain precious speed. In the field, it’s the same cycle—raise, mount, swing. Heavy suits leisurely shots; light thrives on instinct. But “heavy” or “light” isn’t universal—Ted thrived with his 7¾-pound double where I’d struggle.
I’ve settled on a range: 5½ pounds for thick-cover flushes, 6½ for all-purpose grit, 7½ for open shots needing punch. In 2025, options abound—the Montefeltro Ultra Light at 5.2 pounds for agility, the Mossberg 590-RM at 11 pounds for brute force. Every ounce shifts the game. Pick up a few models, swing them, weigh them (check the wood—European walnut shaves ounces over American). Your perfect gun’s out there—it’s just a matter of matching the weight to your hunt.
The One That Got Away
Weight can’t fix everything, though. Years back, Ted and I paddled a canoe onto a Snake River island, shrouded in ground fog. We heard Canada geese yakking 40 yards off. “Sandbar,” Ted whispered. “Split up, meet ‘em in ten.” I crept through weeds, timing my approach. At the signal, we stepped out as a breeze swept the fog away—dozens of geese thrashed skyward, 25 yards out. I swung on one, fired, picked another, fired again. Ted shot twice too. We met in stunned silence. Not a feather fell. “Somehow,” he muttered, eyeing our trusty guns, “it was us.” Weight didn’t matter that day—sometimes, the birds just win.